If you have a straighter, elongated lid shape, like Awkwafina or Chrissy Teigen, a flatter curler will ensure you’re catching all your lashes in one go, rather than having to try angle your face or curler in a finicky manner to ensure your lashes are going in the same direction. Horsley suggests reaching for Shiseido’s Eyelash Curler: “It has a remarkably flatter shape and is great for straighter, shorter lashes. It really creates a natural-looking curl and lift, and is easier for a smaller eye to navigate.” Plus, she mentions that the eye curler pad is “super cushy,” perfect for catching hard-to-reach lashes.